vs Valparaiso (0-5) - Sunday 1/14/24 - 2 pm - ESPN+

Manchester Matt

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 16, 2017
Messages
2,127
I went to a week long ShotDoctor shooting camp back in the day

Anybody go to Dick Baumgartner's basketball shooting camp in Indiana? "Pop it up and get it going, baby."

Now it's just play play play play. The athletes are as athletic as ever. The basketball, imo, sure is DUMBER though.
Well said. I sent my kid to a PGC camp this summer, which included classroom breakdowns and so many drills for guards. It was an investment for sure, but he’s made massive strides.

.Kids got to play games, but I still believe skill development is massively important. If the dates works out, I’ll send him back to the next progression of the camp this summer.
 

Hamdonger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
6,521
Humdinger said:

"The 5 man substitution in the 2nd half...Ryan should have stuck with it longer. Maybe much longer. IMMEDIATELY the first possession the ball is moving much better and the players are moving. It goes in to Schmitt and he makes an excellent post move. He didn't convert but it was one of our best possessions of the game. Then we cut the lead in half - and he starts subbing again."


This moment here frustrated me .. the group on the floor were in sync pretty quick, ball movement, energy, started scoring, cut the lead in half, then a time out, Pedon subs Davis for Schmidt, played good defense still, Davis gets the ball, does not see or look for a teammate, runs down, takes a shot, misses, that in sync thing I mentioned, evaporated immediately. That small disruption was all it took. I don't know what the relationship between Schmidt & Pedon is, head scratcher. Schmidt was fine in that short amount of playing time. Yes he attempted a 3, I'm ok with that, he has shown he can make them. I'd rather have Schmidt taking those over Foster, Lieb, etc.. I feel bad for the kid, what message does pulling a Freshman's redshirt half way through the season to have that kid play less than Lieb minutes over Schmidt. I'm sure there is more to this than I know, god, in away I hope there is.
I deleted that post but we had a good flow completely going on both sides of the ball and I would have liked to see it for a bit longer. It felt like we were going to completely close the deficit.

Clearly Coach Pedon doesn't feel comfortable with Schmitt on the floor. So be it. I'd like to see close to 10 min a game from him, but maybe Chase will step up and fill that slot that we so desperately need. He's got smarts...just needs minutes to catch himself up.

What I like about Ryan is he doesn't take a bunch of time to make a move and he has eyes that see the court. It allows the offense to naturally flow in and out...which is so key to what Pedon wants to do. Myles is a bull and man we need him(!)...but the ball goes in and it takes him 5 seconds to get a shot up and it takes us out of a flow. Myles IS giving us 11 and 7, and 50% plus from 2pt land, though, so I need to stop bitching about him, cause he's very valuable to us.

Kind of the point is...I'm not so much after better individual play. I'm looking for better TEAM play.
 

Hamdonger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
6,521
Well said. I sent my kid to a PGC camp this summer, which included classroom breakdowns and so many drills for guards. It was an investment for sure, but he’s made massive strides.

.Kids got to play games, but I still believe skill development is massively important. If the dates works out, I’ll send him back to the next progression of the camp this summer.
I'm with you. I just mentioned better team play...but I'm totally totally totally into individual SKILL development.
 

ChiRedbirdfan

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
6,607
Vicious circle. We are bad so people are mad and stop coming and stop donating "to make a point" and then wonder why ISU won't get rid of a coach early or do something else. We did that, we owe him $6 million. If donations and fans stop coming in, then it will take longer to pay that off. Then you can't make another move somewhere.
Your point regarding ISU athletics is accurate but I believe over-exaggerated on the financial situation as ISU athletics is primarily funded via student fees and a university contributions. Basically 1/3 student fees, 1/3 university contributions and 1/3 all other (tickets sales, licensing, donations ..etc). Student enrollment is near all time highs so positive numbers there. I reviewed the most recent 5 year (2018-2022) ncaa athletic department financial data and here is the 5 year totals on athletic department recenue:

ISU Redbirds $146,600,000
UNI Panthers $100,799,000
SIU Salukis $94,600,000

SIU/UNI hoops much better than ISU hoops the past 5 years. SUI/UNI football better than ISU football the past 5 years. Hard for me to understand how people can defend ISU ATHLETICS or even remotely critize the fans/alums for not contributing ( I used to contribute but refuse until ISU athletics stops floundering with its strategy and operations)

Brennan and company certainly did not help the situation but ISU athletics was already floundering. They have become a convenient excuse for the failing hoops and football program even though both were already unsuccessful, IMO.

As far as Pedon…too early to pull the plug given state of the program when he arrived. That said he needs to ramp it up big time or he will not last too long.

Feeling down? No need, remember we are the 3 time reining MVC All sports champion!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1651.png
    IMG_1651.png
    7.8 MB · Views: 2
Last edited:

Aggie

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2020
Messages
324
Problem is with the next man up is we can't afford to really do that, at some point we are just kind of stuck. We are still paying Muller and where $6 million short on the indoor. ISU athletics doesn't have the money rolling in to where I wonder how far Brennan and Kinzy set ISU back. At some point we might be left with what we have. I am rooting for Pedon bc he's a nice guy and trying in the community but we really don't have the funds for another 2 year payout
Not saying to buy him out. I agree due to horrendous previous contract ISU in a hole before we even pass go. We are stuck until the end of the current contract. Unless massive improvement in wins versus losses happens in the next 10 games ISU needs to be thinking about the future. I am really worried we go on a 10 game winning streak against a weak schedule, athletic department gets in a tizzy and bam we get an extension. While I believe ISU should be looking for that very successful coach from a lower conference or division that knows how to win. We have several years to be looking. Don’t hire the homer and do not hire the legend, you can never get rid of them if they are not successful. They always have their supporters and defenders that make removal difficult. I would also look for a coach that has a basketball style that is very entertaining and will get attendance back. ISU is going on 30 years of not being asked to go dancing. Thirty years. Other schools have changed it up in two years. We are living in the past and we have to look forward to the future. Where we are today is not a very bright future.
 

ChiRedbirdfan

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
6,607
Football isn't taken into consideration for the the MVC all-sports trophy. MVC and MVFC are 2 completely different conferences.
The point I am making is that we are not focused on winning where it matters most (football, men’s basketball) to fans/alums, students, revenue generation, name recognition…etc. believe it or not some view winning the MVC trophy as a sign that ISU athletics are a success. To each their own
 

SlackBooDom

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2022
Messages
326
Your point regarding ISU athletics is accurate but I believe over-exaggerated on the financial situation as ISU athletics is primarily funded via student fees and a university contributions. Basically 1/3 student fees, 1/3 university contributions and 1/3 all other (tickets sales, licensing, donations ..etc). Student enrollment is near all time highs so positive numbers there. I reviewed the most recent 5 year (2018-2022) ncaa athletic department financial data and here is the 5 year totals on athletic department recenue:

ISU Redbirds $146,600,000
NIU Panthers $100,799,000
SIU Salukis $94,600,000

SIU/UNI hoops much better than ISU hoops the past 5 years. SUI/UNI football better than ISU football the past 5 years. Hard for me to understand how people can defend ISU ATHLETICS or even remotely critize the fans/alums for not contributing ( I used to contribute but refuse until ISU athletics stops floundering with its strategy and operations)

Brennan and company certainly did not help the situation but ISU athletics was already floundering. They have become a convenient excuse for the failing hoops and football program even though both were already unsuccessful, IMO.

As far as Pedon…too early to pull the plug given state of the program when he arrived. That said he needs to ramp it up big time or he will not last too long.

Feeling down? No need, remember we are the 3 time reining MVC All sports champion!
I think without COVID and firing Muller a year earlier then things look very different. COVID coming at the intersection of bad basketball seemed to zap the program of any momentum or energy. They've never recovered from people taking 18 months off of ISU basketball and not wanting to come back to a last place team. Combine that with Brennan's efforts to run off staff, raise prices, increase donations, charge for parking, charge for hospitality and you see the recipe for what we are dealing with now. I have been involved with campus efforts in the past and after COVID the fundraising took an intense downswing for athletics largely due to the new administration and their work.
 

Redbird222

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 18, 2017
Messages
5,398
1.5 years and Pedon is still searching and he currently doesn't have the answers in my opinion

1. Rotations and substitution patterns support this
2. What is the teams identity?
3. Has he recruited the players for his system or players that fit an ideological or philosophical belief that aligns with him but perhaps not the appropriate skill sets to run his style? How does he align the two?
4. I think there is a lot of frustration from fans because we cannot see and articulate the long-term vision. The age roster suggests success this year or next year. If the future is the 3 freshman than we should be recruiting and developing accordingly. It feels like we are flapping in the wind right now versus traveling down a rough stretch of a path to success.
5. We hired an inexperienced coach and he surrounded himself with an inexperienced staff except Judson. I think it shows a lot at times.
6. Perdon's strongest asset is supposed to be his ability to connect with players. It seems like this is wavering right now. Has he set the appropriate guardrails with accountability without knee jerk reactions so players are not looking over their shoulders and scared to make a mistake?

I think this a critical juncture in his ISU tenure. If he doesn't figure it out he may be remembered like Moser ... nice guy the community liked however wasn't ready and therefore didn't get it done.
 

DougSutton

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
414
Yep- I spent a week at Rose Hulman with my hs team in like 93.
@Humdinger I went to the Dick Baumgartner's basketball shooting camp in Indiana for a week as well. Great camp! I remember bringing home one of the basketballs with hand prints on the ball of where to place hands. Great camp experience, probably went around 1990. Great time and memory!

Regarding this team and season, it's been frustrating no doubt. I'll continue to support coach Pedon unless or until he's no longer our coach. I'm happy for my friend Roger Powell getting his first Valley win at Redbird Arena. Valpo is a much tougher school to recruit to than Illinois State and he'll have an uphill battle to become a contender in the Valley there. He has a few talented young players and I'm sure will keep building a team and culture that matches his style. I do believe Valpo is the perfect fit for his personality.

As a side note, I'm paying close attention to Indiana State's success and observing my own bias when we have had openings for head coaches where I've wanted a top assistant from a power program to come in compared to a highly successful coach at a lower tier university.

I can see especially in this NIL/portal era where a coach that has been massively successful in D2 or D3 might be a much better fit for a school in the Valley because these coaches don't rely on top talent recruits or care how many "stars" they are ranked and tend to recruit a different type of player and culture than what a top assistant from a bigger program would. Many of these kids want to go to the highest level program they can go to and if they have success at a Valley school, they may move on to a power 5 program that will offer them more money.

Instead, coaches from D2 build for culture and clearly based on results, they are great floor coaches and leaders of talent. So if/when we're ever in a position to hire a new coach (which I hope happens only after coach Pedon succeeds so much he gets a big pay raise and goes back to Ohio State or another program like that), I'm committed to removing my own previous bias and hope we strongly consider going down a path to find a dominant coach from a lower tier.
 

Redbird222

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 18, 2017
Messages
5,398
1.5 years and Pedon is still searching and he currently doesn't have the answers in my opinion

1. Rotations and substitution patterns support this
2. What is the teams identity?
3. Has he recruited the players for his system or players that fit an ideological or philosophical belief that aligns with him but perhaps not the appropriate skill sets to run his style? How does he align the two?
4. I think there is a lot of frustration from fans because we cannot see and articulate the long-term vision. The age roster suggests success this year or next year. If the future is the 3 freshman than we should be recruiting and developing accordingly. It feels like we are flapping in the wind right now versus traveling down a rough stretch of a path to success.
5. We hired an inexperienced coach and he surrounded himself with an inexperienced staff except Judson. I think it shows a lot at times.
6. Perdon's strongest asset is supposed to be his ability to connect with players. It seems like this is wavering right now. Has he set the appropriate guardrails with accountability without knee jerk reactions so players are not looking over their shoulders and scared to make a mistake?

I think this a critical juncture in his ISU tenure. If he doesn't figure it out he may be remembered like Moser ... nice guy the community liked however wasn't ready and therefore didn't get it done.
I probably should have added that I hope he figures it out. I personally like how interacts with the community.
 

BIGfan

Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
172
5.6%?!?! When I was in H.S. I missed a hook shot in the lane. My coach took me out and asked if I was touching the rim with my left hand while shooting with my right. I said NO. He then said "If you can't touch the rim with one hand you are too far away." I never forgot that quote all the way through college ball, Navy All-Stars and IBL. That is all I could think of Sunday. Maybe if the bricks aren't going in... change your plan.
 

stielowp

Active member
Joined
Nov 18, 2019
Messages
88
I feel like this is in line with some of what I have heard also.
I don't think this team really likes each other. We thought we might have depth and competition at the beginning of the year, but I think instead of improving, the entire team has just hoped that the competition would just get exposed and then they would get their turn. We look very selfish, one reason we don't get many assists, in addition to being poor shooters and finishers inside. I don't see any real leaders on this team. I eliminate the Freshman, because they are supposed to be learning. Our returnees were supposed to be those guys. Lewis is the key to a lot of things. When he plays well, the team plays well. He has the most talent, but he gets frustrated too easily. All of our guards have severe limitations and I don't think they want the other guards to do well. Burford needs the ball and only really scores in transition. Banks looks lost and only seems aggressive late in the clock. Mal has been a non-factor and seems to be checking out more and more each game. Luke is just not very skilled. Davis doesn't seem to have any drive or desire. JK has the skills, but still lacks the physical tools. Pence is having a hard time adjusting and I am worried he may only be as good as a Matt Chastain (another player that dominated small school HS basketball).

I will always support Redbird Basketball, but players and teams like this make it a very long winter. All that being said, it would not surprise me if this team comes out and beats Drake on Wednesday. Drake probably won't be motivated, and hopefully we show a little fight.
 

stielowp

Active member
Joined
Nov 18, 2019
Messages
88
it’s not just the shooting, Birds are playing defense with 5’s jump switching on the perimeter and forcing Banks, Kinziger, Burford to guard bigs on the block; they don’t value FT shooting enough to shoot better than the 50%; the offense simply doesn’t create shots- almost every 3 was on the move tonight and even when Foster gets it on the block, they can triple him cause they know it’s not getting kicked back.

I didn’t see a lack of effort before he pulled everybody- it really feels like the system just isn’t putting players in a position to succeed, it’s not giving them great looks that they are missing, they are missing difficult shots for the most part. On the defensive end, we are still many times just to small to match up if Lewis or Foster are out and the way we play defense doesnt help it(watched Valpo bigs drop time and time again without giving up either great shots or mismatches tonight), teams we play aren’t just that good. This Birds team can be better, it can’t get better players for this year and unless there is a draft choice I don’t know about, playing freshman “for the future” doesn’t make sense in a portal world, if they continue to lose, it will get harder in the future- what I’m opposed to is continuing to do the same thing and expect different results, time to evaluate offensive and defensive playbooks.
The 3's we are missing are what an average D1 team calls "good" shots. We have missed many wide open looks and some of them haven't been close. We also started passing up good looks about 2 weeks ago, our confidence was down then, and now we look afraid to shoot at all.
 

SlackBooDom

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2022
Messages
326
I don't think this team really likes each other. We thought we might have depth and competition at the beginning of the year, but I think instead of improving, the entire team has just hoped that the competition would just get exposed and then they would get their turn. We look very selfish, one reason we don't get many assists, in addition to being poor shooters and finishers inside. I don't see any real leaders on this team. I eliminate the Freshman, because they are supposed to be learning. Our returnees were supposed to be those guys. Lewis is the key to a lot of things. When he plays well, the team plays well. He has the most talent, but he gets frustrated too easily. All of our guards have severe limitations and I don't think they want the other guards to do well. Burford needs the ball and only really scores in transition. Banks looks lost and only seems aggressive late in the clock. Mal has been a non-factor and seems to be checking out more and more each game. Luke is just not very skilled. Davis doesn't seem to have any drive or desire. JK has the skills, but still lacks the physical tools. Pence is having a hard time adjusting and I am worried he may only be as good as a Matt Chastain (another player that dominated small school HS basketball).

I will always support Redbird Basketball, but players and teams like this make it a very long winter. All that being said, it would not surprise me if this team comes out and beats Drake on Wednesday. Drake probably won't be motivated, and hopefully we show a little fight.
It will be interesting to see what the roster looks like next year. I would say one of the biggest knocks on Muller was that he didn't get good basketball players into the program, which I think is overblown slightly but the sentiment is a common one. So far from the portal we've pulled Burford, Knight, Sandage, Poindexter, Petrakis, Kasubke, Lieb, Banks, Foster, Davis. The overall return on that investment is less than average. I'm wondering if we don't see a revamped recruiting effort focusing on JC, D2, D3, NAIA. St. Thomas is having success with several D3 players. Maybe our thinking that P5 scraps will accelerate things at our level is one that needs tweaking. So far the P5 guys we've thought would benefit from a change of level has failed.
 

Redbird222

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 18, 2017
Messages
5,398
The 3's we are missing are what an average D1 team calls "good" shots. We have missed many wide open looks and some of them haven't been close. We also started passing up good looks about 2 weeks ago, our confidence was down then, and now we look afraid to shoot at all.
This 100%
 

cpacmel

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 16, 2017
Messages
3,892
The point I am making is that we are not focused on winning where it matters most (football, men’s basketball) to fans/alums, students, revenue generation, name recognition…etc. believe it or not some view winning the MVC trophy as a sign that ISU athletics are a success. To each their own

I won't go down the road with you regarding men's basketball. Though Muller was the highest-paid coach at ISU and probably in the top 3 for the conference. They certainly could use a designated practice facility.

But Football? I might be wrong about this, but the 2 biggest projects (Cost wise) in the last 12 years or so, were the Hancock stadium remodeling (20 mil?) and the Indoor Practice Facility (11 mil?). Now the Indoor facility will be used for more than Football as is Hancock Stadium. But the main focus is football.
 

Hamdonger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
6,521
@Humdinger I went to the Dick Baumgartner's basketball shooting camp in Indiana for a week as well. Great camp! I remember bringing home one of the basketballs with hand prints on the ball of where to place hands. Great camp experience, probably went around 1990. Great time and memory!

Regarding this team and season, it's been frustrating no doubt. I'll continue to support coach Pedon unless or until he's no longer our coach. I'm happy for my friend Roger Powell getting his first Valley win at Redbird Arena. Valpo is a much tougher school to recruit to than Illinois State and he'll have an uphill battle to become a contender in the Valley there. He has a few talented young players and I'm sure will keep building a team and culture that matches his style. I do believe Valpo is the perfect fit for his personality.

As a side note, I'm paying close attention to Indiana State's success and observing my own bias when we have had openings for head coaches where I've wanted a top assistant from a power program to come in compared to a highly successful coach at a lower tier university.

I can see especially in this NIL/portal era where a coach that has been massively successful in D2 or D3 might be a much better fit for a school in the Valley because these coaches don't rely on top talent recruits or care how many "stars" they are ranked and tend to recruit a different type of player and culture than what a top assistant from a bigger program would. Many of these kids want to go to the highest level program they can go to and if they have success at a Valley school, they may move on to a power 5 program that will offer them more money.

Instead, coaches from D2 build for culture and clearly based on results, they are great floor coaches and leaders of talent. So if/when we're ever in a position to hire a new coach (which I hope happens only after coach Pedon succeeds so much he gets a big pay raise and goes back to Ohio State or another program like that), I'm committed to removing my own previous bias and hope we strongly consider going down a path to find a dominant coach from a lower tier.
Doug...that printed hand on the ball was absolute genius. Made some very good shooters! I loved the camp because they broke you up immediately so your 'team' was guys from other schools and states. Man I loved that. I attended 2 years in late 80's.

I really REALLY concur with you on having a coach who has already SUCCESSFULLY run a program. I'd love Ben McCollum. But I almost think a guy like Ben is better off staying where he's at vs. an opportunity at a midmajor. Given NIL...I don't see how you can have long term MM success.

I hope he gets a P5 shot.
 
Last edited:

Hamdonger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
6,521
Your point regarding ISU athletics is accurate but I believe over-exaggerated on the financial situation as ISU athletics is primarily funded via student fees and a university contributions. Basically 1/3 student fees, 1/3 university contributions and 1/3 all other (tickets sales, licensing, donations ..etc). Student enrollment is near all time highs so positive numbers there. I reviewed the most recent 5 year (2018-2022) ncaa athletic department financial data and here is the 5 year totals on athletic department recenue:

ISU Redbirds $146,600,000
NIU Panthers $100,799,000
SIU Salukis $94,600,000

SIU/UNI hoops much better than ISU hoops the past 5 years. SUI/UNI football better than ISU football the past 5 years. Hard for me to understand how people can defend ISU ATHLETICS or even remotely critize the fans/alums for not contributing ( I used to contribute but refuse until ISU athletics stops floundering with its strategy and operations)

Brennan and company certainly did not help the situation but ISU athletics was already floundering. They have become a convenient excuse for the failing hoops and football program even though both were already unsuccessful, IMO.

As far as Pedon…too early to pull the plug given state of the program when he arrived. That said he needs to ramp it up big time or he will not last too long.

Feeling down? No need, remember we are the 3 time reining MVC All sports champion!
Man you always bring good info to the table, no matter where the reader stands.
 

Hamdonger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
6,521
I don't think this team really likes each other. We thought we might have depth and competition at the beginning of the year, but I think instead of improving, the entire team has just hoped that the competition would just get exposed and then they would get their turn. We look very selfish, one reason we don't get many assists, in addition to being poor shooters and finishers inside. I don't see any real leaders on this team. I eliminate the Freshman, because they are supposed to be learning. Our returnees were supposed to be those guys. Lewis is the key to a lot of things. When he plays well, the team plays well. He has the most talent, but he gets frustrated too easily. All of our guards have severe limitations and I don't think they want the other guards to do well. Burford needs the ball and only really scores in transition. Banks looks lost and only seems aggressive late in the clock. Mal has been a non-factor and seems to be checking out more and more each game. Luke is just not very skilled. Davis doesn't seem to have any drive or desire. JK has the skills, but still lacks the physical tools. Pence is having a hard time adjusting and I am worried he may only be as good as a Matt Chastain (another player that dominated small school HS basketball).

I will always support Redbird Basketball, but players and teams like this make it a very long winter. All that being said, it would not surprise me if this team comes out and beats Drake on Wednesday. Drake probably won't be motivated, and hopefully we show a little fight.
A lot of good insight here. I will say I am liking how Davis has been playing...even though he didn't score yesterday. I think he has a knack for the ball. I feel like once he believed that Pedon bought into him, it released him to play much more free.
 

Bird Friend

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
12,586
U
It will be interesting to see what the roster looks like next year. I would say one of the biggest knocks on Muller was that he didn't get good basketball players into the program, which I think is overblown slightly but the sentiment is a common one. So far from the portal we've pulled Burford, Knight, Sandage, Poindexter, Petrakis, Kasubke, Lieb, Banks, Foster, Davis. The overall return on that investment is less than average. I'm wondering if we don't see a revamped recruiting effort focusing on JC, D2, D3, NAIA. St. Thomas is having success with several D3 players. Maybe our thinking that P5 scraps will accelerate things at our level is one that needs tweaking. So far the P5 guys we've thought would benefit from a change of level has failed.
Unless we have some guys opt to move on, the next year’s roster will look pretty much the same. We lose Lewis and Schmitt. We have two HS recruits, a 4 and a 2.
 
Top Bottom