TreRoberson4Heisman
Active member
- Joined
- Jul 18, 2017
- Messages
- 1,041
Big time get. Welcome sunshine! Is Kolbe going to feel the noise during camp? https://247sports.com/Player/Brady-Davis-40054
TreRoberson4Heisman said:Big time get. Welcome sunshine! Is Kolbe going to feel the noise during camp? https://247sports.com/Player/Brady-Davis-40054
TIMMY said:Don't ya just love competition?
ISUBU said:Six QBs on the roster this fall barring changes. Gotta imagine there may be a position change or transfer in there somewhere.
Brady Davis almost never played at Memphis. Memphis lists 2015 as his freshman year and as a redshirt, but they also give him one game appearance. I don't really understand that.
2016 lost to injury.
2017 Appeared in one game, rushing for one yard.
This is a puzzling transfer to me.
I have all the confidence possible that Coach Beathard will correctly evaluate the talent and make the right decision. In Beathard I trust.Sanantoniobird said:From the limited info available, I don’t see him head-and-shoulders over anyone we currently have (out of Kolbe, Brodnax, Hatfield, or Smith).
That's a great call. Beathard will always do what's best for the team. Now I'm not sayin this kid is better than anyone on the roster. No one should. We have no clue until we see him play. But I distinctly remember some saying Winkler was better than Roberson. I can't wait to see this play out. Timmy might have to play his coaches card and check it out first hand. Love it!RBFANTOO said:I have all the confidence possible that Coach Beathard will correctly evaluate the talent and make the right decision. In Beathard I trust.Sanantoniobird said:From the limited info available, I don’t see him head-and-shoulders over anyone we currently have (out of Kolbe, Brodnax, Hatfield, or Smith).
This.Adunk33 said:ISUBU said:Six QBs on the roster this fall barring changes. Gotta imagine there may be a position change or transfer in there somewhere.
Brady Davis almost never played at Memphis. Memphis lists 2015 as his freshman year and as a redshirt, but they also give him one game appearance. I don't really understand that.
2016 lost to injury.
2017 Appeared in one game, rushing for one yard.
This is a puzzling transfer to me.
...I remember when Hatfield was recruited, Spack wanted to make him a safety. Then you have Smith, who has some game experience that you can't look past. You know what they say, if you think you have 6 QBs, you probably don't have one.
Adunk33 said:ISUBU said:Six QBs on the roster this fall barring changes. Gotta imagine there may be a position change or transfer in there somewhere.
Brady Davis almost never played at Memphis. Memphis lists 2015 as his freshman year and as a redshirt, but they also give him one game appearance. I don't really understand that.
2016 lost to injury.
2017 Appeared in one game, rushing for one yard.
This is a puzzling transfer to me.
This was my thought. Appears he was highly regarded out of HS and then got injured, and was never able to get over the hump of the 3rd string. I don't know, I've liked what I've seen out of Malachi, and Hatfield if Kolbe is the starter. I remember when Hatfield was recruited, Spack wanted to make him a safety. Then you have Smith, who has some game experience that you can't look past. You know what they say, if you think you have 6 QBs, you probably don't have one.
TIMMY said:That's a great call. Beathard will always do what's best for the team. Now I'm not sayin this kid is better than anyone on the roster. No one should. We have no clue until we see him play. But I distinctly remember some saying Winkler was better than Roberson.
Total Red said:TIMMY said:That's a great call. Beathard will always do what's best for the team. Now I'm not sayin this kid is better than anyone on the roster. No one should. We have no clue until we see him play. But I distinctly remember some saying Winkler was better than Roberson.
I'd be interested in his exact words. Did he say Winkler was better or just ahead at that time?
When Roberson arrived Winkler had the experience advantage as the returning starter and he knew the receivers. He did look better early on especially in the passing game. Even so we knew that Roberson had special skills running with the ball and those couldn't be fully evaluated in practice because we didn't want him tackled. They became very apparent later on.
fourthandshort said:love that there will be more competition ... but if I had to guess, this might also free up Hatfield or Broadnax for a position change. Spack had originally planned on Hatfield moving into secondary. And I don't yet see Broadnax as full time QB .. but offseason may have been good for him and maybe he has more to contribute than he showed in SDSU game passing-wise. He played well for a RS FR getting thrust into starting roll in a huge game .. but you have to be a throwing threat to be an effective dual threat QB.
Don't know what to make of this transfer .. guessing he has some talent, but may have lost confidence from sitting and the injury. Like others, I have fully trust Beathard to figure this out. Our run game will take a lot of pressure of whoever is at QB .. defenses will have to stay in the box, safeties will have to provide more run support ... going to be a very interesting season on offense.